Plessy appealed the case to the louisiana state supreme court, which affirmed the decision that the louisiana law as constitutional. The 1896 united states supreme court decision in this case upheld the legality of state laws that required racial segregation in public facilities known as the separate but equal doctrine. In the 1890s, a famous court case occurred in louisiana known as plessy v. Ferguson decision made legal a system of separate but equal racial segregation not overruled until 1954. Plessy vs ferguson is the famous united states supreme court case that dealt with the the supreme court deciding to uphold the constitutionality of the state laws that required racial segregation in private businesses, under the doctrine separate but equal. He believed that segregation, the legal separation of blacks and whites, was unfair.
Among the outstanding monograph essays on the topic are. Ferguson found plessy guilty of refusing to leave the white car. Justia us law us case law us supreme court volume 163 plessy v. Plessy decided to appeal the decision to the supreme court of louisiana, but that court upheld fergusons opinion. Plessy was a united states citizen living in louisiana. In 1896, the supreme court of the united states found homer plessy guilty once again. Using the full text of the courts opinion, along with a selection of responses to the ruling, brook thomas allows students to recreate a context of the complicated debates and conditions in which the decision took place. Despite the historical significance of plessy, its historiography is sparing, cur sory, tangential and misleading. Separate but equal racial segregation in the united states.
Facts of the case in the late 1800s, the state of louisiana passed a law called the separate car act. Justice john marshall harlan 18331911 dissented, charging that the judgment this day rendered will, in time, prove to be quite as pernicious as the decision made by this tribunal in the dred sco. Ferguson decision upheld the principle of racial segregation over the next halfcentury. The decision legitimized the many state laws reestablishing racial segregation that had. Once the court backed up the louisiana law, it was accepting to have a. Plessy then decided to take his case to the united states supreme court. Ferguson, judge of the criminal district court for the parish of orleans, and setting forth, in substance, the following facts.
Homer plessy, who was considered to be 78ths of caucasian descent. This topnotch resource is included in the civil rights movement unit bundle. The case coming on for a hearing before the supreme court, that court was of opinion that. The federal government allowed for racial segregation to be constitutional and due to the decisions made in this case, the fight for civil rights in the united states was set back for several decades. Justice brown, after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.
This legal case probes the intent and scope of the th, 14th, and 15th. In this outstanding activity, students learn about the controversial case of homer plessy, his role in plessy v. The phrase separate but equal was a legal doctrine in u. Ferguson set the case up by explaining this is a significant case in u.
Ironically, although the plessy decision has been discredited, rejected, and generally. Ferguson 1896 upheld a louisiana law demanding segregated railway cars and established the doctrine of separate but equal in american constitutional law. Featuring 100 milestone documents of american history from the national archives. Board of education 1954, this decision embraced the nowdiscredited idea that separate but equal treatment for whites and africanamericans is permissible under the fourteenth amendment. Royal order of october 1749 establishing the instructions to be followed by the. Medley states that jefferson davis surrendered at appomattox courthouse. Supreme court case concerning whether racial segregation laws were constitutional. Oct 07, 2006 in 1896, the supreme court heard the case of plessy v.
Those decisions cannot be guides in the era introduced by the recent amendments of the supreme law. John howard ferguson born june 10, 1838, was an american lawyer and judge from louisiana, most famous as the defendant in the plessy vs. The committee of citizens challenged the constitutionality of the law on behalf of plessy, claiming it violated the equal protection law under the 14th amendment. The petitioner was subsequently brought before the recorder of the city for preliminary examination, and committed for trial to the criminal district court for the parish of orleans, where an information was filed. Ferguson was the first major inquiry into the meaning of the fourteenth amendments 1868 equalprotection clause. It is a powerful story of organizing, fundraising, the use of the media, legal strategies, and more. Those decisions cannot be guides in the era introduced by the recent. Ferguson was a court case that took place within the state of louisiana with regard to the investigation and analysis of racial discrimination suffered by african americans.
Ferguson, with biographies of three of the key players homer plessy, john ferguson, and albion tourgee, we as freemen has a huge number of shortcomings that are hard to ignore. What did the supreme court rule with regards to the civil rights act of 1875 in a case decided in 1883. In 1896, the supreme court issued its decision in plessy v. In this outstanding activity, students learn about the controversial case of homer plessy.
This case did not change, add or take anything away from. Ferguson, the united states supreme court established the separate but equal doctrine as the basis for public facilities, including schools, in the south. He was solicited by the comite des citoyens committee of citizens, a group of new orleans residents who sought to repeal the act. Brown of michigan ended in a 71 decision of the court that backed up the louisiana law requiring segregation. This law indicated that railroad companies must have equal, but separate train carts for whites and blacks. In other words, whites and blacks sat separately from each other, in different carts. The case coming on for hearing before the supreme court, that court was of opinion that the law under which the. Lionel adams represented the state of louisiana, and was one of the best trial lawyers at the time.
Ferguson was born the third and last child to baptist parents, john h. Justice john marshall harlan 18331911 dissented, charging that the judgment this day rendered will, in time, prove to be quite as pernicious as the decision made by this tribunal in the dred scott case. After this, jim crow laws, which were a system of laws meant to discriminate against. He argued that the whites would be arrested if they sat in the jim crow cars just like plessy had been arrested for sitting in the whites only car. Plessy was only oneeighths black and seveneighths white, but under louisiana law, he was considered black and therefore required to sit in the colored car. Justice henry brown of michigan delivered the majority opinion, which sustained the constitutionality of.
Louisiana enacted the separate car act, which required separate railway cars for blacks and whites. John howard ferguson chose a different vocational path and taught school in his early years. They ruled that segregation was legal, as long as the facilities of blacks and. Ferguson about the organizing by the comite des citoyens that led to plessy v.
Even though he was oneeighth african american, he was still required to sit in a jim crow car, along with african americans, separated from the whites. For example, there were separate schools, parks, water fountains, and bathrooms for african americans and for whites. In 1892, homer plessy who was seveneighths caucasian agreed to participate in a test to challenge the act. The court found for ferguson and the supreme court granted cert. Supreme court that upheld the constitutionality of racial segregation laws for public facilities as long as the segregated facilities were equal in quality a doctrine that came to be known as separate but equal.
In 1896, the supreme court heard the case of plessy v. Ferguson allowed separate but equal, also known as segregation, to become law in the united states. Plessy was seveneighths caucasian and oneeighth african. Ferguson is louisianas law mandating racial segregation on its trains an unconstitutional infringement on both the privileges and immunities and the equal protection clauses of the fourteenth amendment. Reading breaking the rules you may have heard the saying, some rules are meant to be broken. Describe what happened to the struggle for race equality after the decision. Ferguson case, decided by the united states supreme court, and establishing the doctrine of separate but equal that would remain the law of land until overturned in 1954. This case turns upon the constitutionality of an act of the general assembly of the state of louisiana, passed in 1890, providing for separate railway carriages for the white and colored races.
Supreme court decision that upheld the constitutionality of racial segregation under the separate but equal doctrine. Justice henry brown of michigan delivered the majority opinion, which sustained the constitutionality of louisianas jim crow law. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Plessy vs ferguson historical perspective of to kill a mockingbird. Ferguson 1896 abridged 1 the statute of louisiana, acts of 1890, c. Includes images of original primary source documents, lesson plans, teacher and student competitions, and educational resources. Vann woodwards cursory historical account of the case in his article the birth of jim crow. Well explore the practices of many southern states during this time in american history, learn the details of. Homer plessy, a partblack man, was arrested for refusing to move out of the white section of train. Therefore, ferguson found plessy guilty and declared the separate car act constitutional.
Melville fuller, stephen field, horace gray, henry brown. The plessy v ferguson case started in 1892, when homer plessy was boarding a train which took place in new orleans, louisiana. What is missing from the courts analysisor, more to the point. Separate but equal is the constitutional meaning of the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. These laws required african americans and whites to use different public facilities see jim crow law. While ferguson had dismissed an earlier test case because it involved interstate travel, the federal governments exclusive jurisdiction, in plessy s allinstate case, the judge ruled that the. The 1896 united states supreme court decision in this case upheld the legality of state laws that required racial segregation in public. What was the significance of the supreme courts decision in plessy v.
Ferguson 163 us 537 1896 is a scotus case that reinforced that separate but equal does not violate the constitution. Plessy, a louisiana citizen of african american descent, was asked to move from the caucasian railway car. The jim crow laws had replaced the infamous black codes, which had restricted the civil rights and civil liberties of freed slaves with no pretense of equality during the reconstruction era. The state of louisiana had passed the separate car act, which required railway companies to have separate but equal train cars for black people and white. Ferguson was one of the most important court cases in black history. Ferguson on june 7, 1892, a 30yearold colored shoemaker named homer plessy was jailed for sitting in the white car of the east louisiana railroad. Ferguson, judge of the criminal district court for the parish of orleans, and. Ferguson was the first major inquiry into the meaning of the fourteenth amendments 1868 equalprotection. While ferguson had dismissed an earlier test case because it involved interstate travel, the federal governments exclusive jurisdiction, in plessys allinstate case, the judge ruled that the. This was an example of the separate but equal statement.
1449 398 380 715 958 599 1387 1343 843 852 1380 538 460 1141 519 245 1303 821 1239 1180 877 601 1136 937 901 153 630 1350 1036 1310 281 1303